I can say they are different in terms of the instruments that are used (conventional vs. I can say that the two songs are similar in the sense of their melodies and texture of the songs. Additionally, at 0:52 they I really enjoy when they add the forks into the melody at the chorus, I think it gives the beat of the song an interesting twist. For example at 1:46 they incorporate the lyrics from “No Scrubs” by TLC. These singers also add different songs that also fit into the similar beat produced by the original song. In the video we can see that they use instruments like a jack in the box, pebbles, and forks. Now, as we move on to the variation of Ed Sheeran’s song which includes more unconventional instruments, has a lot of texture as well. These three instruments is what gives the song its catchy beat.
The song’s sounds includes a guitar, an instrument that sounds something like a xylophone, and a guitar. The original song by Ed Sheeran is a very textured song. At 2:50, the singers repeats the chorus again, so this repetition emphasizes the sadness that he experiences. At 1:40, during the bridge of the song, the dynamics become louder as he sings more powerfully, adding an emotional impact as the listeners can feel his pain. There is a thin texture because the voice is the main melody and the piano is the only harmony. In Calum Scott’s version, the instrumentations consist of piano and voice, creating a more somber atmosphere throughout the song than the original, which is very upbeat. At 2:23, there is little background instrumentals, creating a thin texture with the singer singing the main melody. At 0:38, there is a higher-pitched drum sound adding a unique timbre to the song. Starting from 0:08, the deep percussion keeps the pulse that is the foundation of the song. The instrumentation consists of synths and percussion. However, Robyn’s version of the song is much more upbeat and has a faster tempo. Both songs are in the same verse-chorus form that is typical of popular music. Although they are essentially the same song, the original and the cover have very different vibes because of many musical changes. I am choosing one of my favorite pop songs, Dancing On My Own by Robyn and the cover by Calum Scott.